Boston: Did I Say Too Much?

"Shadows and Sun" (Cambridge, Mass., April 2013) @ Martha Nichols

Sometimes, I hate this world. Or not the world, but its dangers and all that can hurt my son. On April 15, after bombs tore apart the finish line of the Boston Marathon, one of those dangerous tentacles slipped past me. I imagined green scales tightening around my child’s neck, the joyous light draining from his eleven-year-old eyes.

This morning, we listened to the news. My son said he was glad we’d told him—even when my husband showed him the “Marathon terror” banner on the front page of the Boston Globe, complete with graphic photo of a victim, rescue workers, a sidewalk that looked spray-painted red. He’d been furious when we hid the headlines about Newtown after it happened. He’d insisted last December that he wanted to know.

But I’m still wondering if I told him too much about the Boston bombing, if it was wrong for him to find out just as I was finding out, my response unprocessed and far from an ultra-rational “teachable moment.” Sometimes, ignorance really is bliss. It is our Garden, the one we walk through every day with a child.

Before we knew, I picked up my son at his vacation camp. No school this week. Patriot’s Day, the Marathon, the streets around us sweetly and strangely empty. We strolled home through our Cambridge neighborhood, carrying the candles he’d made that afternoon. It was brisk and sunny, daffodils and hyacinths bursting free along the curbs.

"Our Shadows"
@ Martha Nichols

We stopped at a local market for a snack. By then, as I found out later, the bombs had gone off in downtown Boston. In Copley Square, across from the Boston Public Library, places we’d visited many times. But at the store, nobody told us. My son chattered cheerfully about his candles, as the kind woman at the register asked about them, wanting to know if they could float.

Then back out into the spring day, walking the last blocks toward home, past beds of dying crocuses, more daffodils and the first tulips. Even before I unlocked our front door, I was savoring the nap I needed.

My son would have his snack (Doritos and orange juice), work on the story he told me he was writing, play his Lego Lord of the Rings game on the Wii. I could close my eyes and disappear, because we were home. For a few moments, I didn’t have to worry.

When I woke from that nap, I learned that wasn’t true. I can’t claim prescience. I didn’t wake up knowing something terrible had occurred. But it’s also true that I was still groggy when my husband arrived home a few minutes later. By then, I was sitting in my downstairs office, about to check my email.

“Don’t you know what happened?” he asked.

“What?” It was shadowy in my office, which faces east, the maple trees in back just starting to bud. I felt a scratching claw inside my chest.

He told me. Raw information. I didn’t understand. I peppered him with questions, wanting details, not wanting details.

“Why are you whispering?” he asked.

Then I shot into the next room, where my son was still sending Legolas the Elf into the fray against a host of Orcs. I told him we had to turn on the TV now.

Several hours after it happened, we watched the bombs explode, over and over, my boy whimpering in my arms. I cried when I heard an eight-year-old had been killed.

My son hugged me then, trying to comfort me. That wasn’t right. We can’t let fear…we can’t. But I couldn’t stop staring at the screen, the replay of the two explosions, aerial views of the library and Trinity Church, the news ticker about dead and wounded in local hospitals, about what President Obama said, about a moment of silence.

“How could anybody do that?” my son asked.

“It was such a beautiful day,” my husband kept saying on the phone.

"Blue Flower" @ Martha Nichols

Memories, memories—what do you do with all the memories, except remember? Exhaustion followed the shock and tears, as I remembered the paranoia after 9/11, how it had sapped our collective spirit.

Just this past weekend, my son and I took a “photo excusion” around the neighborhood, snapping pictures of flowers and sidewalks and storefronts. I captured him huddled over a crocus for a closeup with his camera—then his skinny arms stretched in a dance move up a concrete wall—then our shadows together on an unmarred sidewalk.

Today I told him that we have to live our lives as if we aren’t afraid. I told him it would be okay. I have no way of knowing—and he knows that, too—but I said the words. The fear that whacked me to earth is not his yet, and fear is what defeats joy. The most terrible thing can become beautiful, if we focus on resilience, on innocence regained.

I didn’t tell him this. People, grown-up people, need to experience a whole series of banner headlines, of shock and recovery, for such beauty to make any sense.

And yet, maybe he—a Vietnamese adoptee, a not-so-little boy who now worries about all the kids in orphanages we saw on our last trip to Vietnam—maybe he does understand. Certainly I should never underestimate what he doesn’t say.

When we finally sat down to dinner Monday evening, he wanted to light one of his candles. A memorial, he said, just as we lit a candle for my mother, who died a few months ago. His candle burned beautifully, glowing pink and blue from within.

“Can I blow it out?” he asked.

“Why?” I asked.

“Because I want to.”

“Because it’s fun,” my husband said. “Then you can light it again. I know you.”

My boy looked at me, the mischievous spark back in his eyes. I wondered how many times he’d blow out the flame and relight it, if that fascination could be limitless.

He grinned.


Éomer and Aragorn stood together on the Deeping Wall. They heard the roar of voices and the thudding of rams; and then in a sudden flash of light they beheld the peril of the gates.

“Come!” said Aragorn. “This is the hour when we draw swords together!”

….Charging from the side, they hurled themselves upon the wild men. Andúril rose and fell, gleaming with white fire. A shout went up from the wall and tower: “Andúril! Andúril! goes to war. The Blade that was Broken shines again!”

— from The Two Towers by J.R.R. Tolkien


2 thoughts on “Boston: Did I Say Too Much?

  1. This is a perfect piece in many ways. It’s as good a way to get in the face of anyone who would do what was done; it’s an ode to a love for the easy innocence that will inevitably feel like it is leaving your life as your son grows up; and it is a reminder, perhaps, that you should come back to in about five years that that innocence is a real thing and it will never leave, really.

    If you do your job as a parent, that innocence will become strength and love which is the best sword of all.

  2. I love this, DB: “It’s an ode to a love for the easy innocence that will inevitably feel like it is leaving your life as your son grows up.”

    It many ways, this whole experience just feels like I’ve been shocked into the inevitable, anyway–kids grow up. And yet, innocence can remain a little flame inside forever, if you feel loved. I do believe that. It gives us the capacity to hope.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *



This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.